- Talentpool Selection
About In House Tax

About In House Tax

This weblog is a news and views site for tax professionals within the UK and international in-house tax community.  You will find information about appointments and people moves in and around the in-house tax market, issues affecting the in-house tax professional, opinions on the state of the tax job market, updates on tax technology, and other general thoughts of the day.

Hope you find it useful.

My Photo
Location: St Albans, United Kingdom

This site has been developed by Simon Godley, who also runs the niche tax recruitment company Talentpool Selection . Simon spends a lot of his time placing tax specialists into FTSE companies, large in-bound groups and some professional services organisations. He also recruits and is well networked around the UK tax technology and VAT markets.

Tax News

Tax Temps - who employs you?

Wednesday, 5 March 2008

By Simon Godley
(Legal source: Field Fisher Waterhouse LLP)

In the long-awaited decision of James v London Borough of Greenwich, the Court of Appeal has upheld the decision of the employment tribunal that an agency worker, supplied by an employment agency, was not employed by the end-user (and therefore was not entitled to those statutory rights which are only available to employees, such as the right not to be unfairly dismissed).

The Court of Appeal has clarified, to some extent, in what circumstances an agency worker is or is not an employee of the end user, emphasising that the implication of a contract of service must be necessary to give effect to the business reality of a relationship between the worker and end user.

The Court of Appeal confirmed that the correct legal question is not whether the individual is an "agency worker" but whether he is employed by the end user under a contract of employment. The two types of contract - agency agreement and contract of employment - are not necessarily mutually exclusive and it is legally possible for a worker to have one kind of contract with the agency and another with the end user. A tribunal should therefore assess the factual evidence carefully to determine whether the individual is an employee. Where there is no express contract, the tribunal must consider whether it is necessary to imply a contract of employment between the parties.

In this case, the tribunal was entitled to conclude that the individual, Ms James, was not an employee of the end user (the Council) because there was no express or implied contractual relationship between her and the Council. Her only express contractual relationship was with the employment agency and, similarly, the Council's only express contractual relationship was also with the agency. The tribunal was correct when it found that it was unnecessary to imply a third contract between Ms James and the Council to give business reality to the relationship between the parties: what both Ms James and the Council did was fully explained by the express contracts they had respectively entered into with the employment agency.
Interestingly, the Court added that it is aware of the controversy at both a domestic and EU level about the absence of job protection for agency workers. However, it emphasised that courts and tribunals cannot confer the right not to be unfairly dismissed on a worker who does not have a contract of employment. It is not for them to express views about a change or to initiate change: this is a matter of social and economic policy for debate in and decision by Parliament.

The above case shows that the whole area of companies 'employing' temps via agencies is still a bit of a minefield, particularly regarding the rights of the worker (temp). It seems that the pressure is on the agencies to be very clear about contracts that are put in place, and between which parties.

Any other input or views on this would be very welcome.

Labels: , ,

posted by Simon Godley


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

If you are someone who is involved with recruitment within the tax field (eg Head of Tax, Head of Finance or HR Adviser) and would like to receive our quarterly in-house tax newsletter Talentpool Extra, please fill in your details below:

Your email address will not be passed on to third parties.